Finding the right nonstick pizza pan with holes for crispy crust depends on your oven size, how many people you feed, and how much you value easy cleanup. While every pan here uses holes to move air and crisp your crust, they differ in size, handle design, and the type of nonstick coating used. If you want a 13-inch pan, you might look at the Farberware Nonstick Crisper Pan, while those with smaller toaster ovens often prefer the Breville Pizza Crisper.
| # | Product | ||
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 |  | Farberware Nonstick Crisper Pan Best Overall | Check Price |
| 2 |  | Breville Pizza Crisper Best for Toaster Ovens | Check Price |
| 3 |  | casaWare Perforated Pizza Pan Best Ceramic Coating | Check Price |
| 4 |  | Emporio Kitchen 16 Inch Pan Best for Large Pizzas | Check Price |
| 5 |  | ZOEHROWS Pizza Pan Best With Silicone Handles | Check Price |
| 6 |  | Wilton Non-Stick Pizza Pan Best PFAS-Free Option | Check Price |
| 7 |  | TaiZhiBeFn Small Pizza Pan Best for Personal Pizzas | Check Price |
1. Farberware Nonstick Bakeware Round Pizza/Crisper Pan
Best for: Someone wanting a reliable, standard-sized pan for everyday pizza baking.
This 13-inch pan is built for the average home cook who needs consistent performance. Its heavy-duty construction is designed to resist warping, which ensures the pan stays flat even when it gets hot. The nonstick coating covers both the inside and outside, making it easy to slide your pizza off and clean the pan once you finish eating.
Because it’s rated for heat up to 450 degrees F, it handles most standard pizza recipes with ease. It’s a solid choice for someone who wants a straightforward, durable tool without extra features. If you need a pan for extremely high-heat baking or specialized ovens, this might not be your best match.
Good if:
- You want a standard 13-inch size for most recipes.
- You prefer easy cleaning with a dual-sided nonstick coating.
Skip it if:
- You require a pan for temperatures higher than 450 degrees F.
- You need specific handles for moving the pan in and out of the oven.
2. Breville BOV800PC Pizza Crisper
Best for: Owners of Breville smart ovens who want a perfect fit.
This pan is specifically designed to work with several Breville Smart Oven models. The 1/3 inch holes are sized to ensure hot air flows properly around the crust, creating a golden, crunchy result. While it’s made to be a specialized accessory, it remains versatile enough to function in any standard household wall oven.
The nonstick surface is meant to save you from scrubbing, so you can spend your time eating rather than cleaning. It’s a great pick for someone who already owns a compatible smart oven and wants a matching accessory. If you’re looking for a larger pan for big family gatherings, this model may feel too small.
Good if:
- You own a Breville Smart Oven and want a matching accessory.
- You want specific 1/3 inch holes for better airflow.
- You prefer a pan that works in both toaster and conventional ovens.
Skip it if:
- You need a larger surface area for big pizzas.
- You’re looking for a pan with extra safety features like silicone handles.
3. casaWare Perforated Pizza Pan 12-inch
Best for: Bakers who prefer a ceramic-based nonstick surface.
This 12-inch pan uses a silver granite ceramic coating, which is a different approach than traditional chemical nonstick layers. It’s built from carbon steel and is designed to handle temperatures up to 450 F without peeling or blistering. The ceramic surface is meant to be chemically inert, providing a smooth release for your pizza or garlic bread.
The pan is 0.6mm thick, which gives it a sturdy feel during use. Because of the ceramic coating, you should be careful not to immerse it in water and avoid using it in a microwave. This is a great option for those who prioritize ceramic technology over standard coatings.
If you’re choosing between this and a standard metal pan, look at your cleaning routine. Because this surface is derived from quartz sand, you only need to wipe or scrub it softly to release food. If you soak it in water, you risk damaging the integrity of the coating.
Good if:
- You prefer a ceramic nonstick surface over traditional coatings.
- You want a pan that’s free of PFOA, PTFE, and PFAS.
- You appreciate a high-fashion look with granite-style flecks.
Skip it if:
- You want a pan that’s fully dishwasher safe.
- You need a size larger than 12 inches for your meals.
- You rely on microwave cooking for your snacks.
4. Emporio Kitchen Non-Stick Pizza Pan 2 Pack
Best for: Families or anyone baking extra-large, loaded pizzas.
When you need more space for toppings or a large family pie, this 16-inch pan provides the extra room you need. It’s crafted from 0.6mm carbon steel to keep it from warping under the weight of a heavy, loaded pizza. The perforations are designed to prevent soggy bottoms by letting moisture escape while the crust bakes.
This pan is safe for temperatures up to 450°F, making it a rugged choice for frequent use. It comes in a two-pack, which is useful if you’re feeding a crowd and need to bake more than one pizza at a time. It isn’t the best choice if you have a small oven, as it may not fit comfortably.
Good if:
- You need a large 16-inch surface for family-sized meals.
- You want the value of a two-pack set.
- You prefer a durable, 0.6mm thick carbon steel construction.
Skip it if:
- You have a compact or standard-sized toaster oven.
- You only ever bake single-serving pizzas.
5. ZOEHROWS 13 Inch Pizza Pan
The standout feature here is the addition of silicone handles. These make it much easier to pull your pizza out of a hot oven without the risk of accidental burns. This pan comes in a two-pack and is designed to be multifunctional. You can use it for bacon, sandwiches, and pastries just as effectively as pizza.
The pan is built from carbon steel to ensure even heating. The bottom is equipped with cooling holes to improve air circulation. This design choice ensures the crust gets crispy on the outside while the inside remains tender. If you struggle with soggy crusts, these holes are the specific feature that will solve your problem.
The nonstick coating simplifies cleanup after a busy meal. Because the material is dishwasher safe, you can save time by skipping manual scrubbing. However, check your oven dimensions before purchasing. The pan measures 14.8 inches in length, including the handles. If your oven rack is narrow, these grips might exceed the available width.
Use these pans when you need to cook multiple items at once, such as during a dinner party or meal prep. If you’re baking delicate pastries, the nonstick surface allows for easy release without tearing. Avoid using metal utensils on the coating, as this will shorten the lifespan of the nonstick layer. If you prioritize a minimalist design, the protruding handles may feel unnecessary. For those who prioritize safety and ease of handling, these pans offer a practical, durable solution.
6. Wilton Silver Non-Stick Pizza Pan
Best for: Those who want a PFAS-free baking option.
Wilton focuses on a durable, cold-rolled steel design that helps prevent hot spots during baking. This 12-inch pan is made without PFAS, which is a common priority for many modern home bakers. It’s built to be dishwasher safe and provides a reliable, consistent performance for everyday favorites like flatbreads or giant cookies.
The pan is designed to be versatile, moving easily from crisping homemade pizza to reheating leftovers. Because it’s made from cold-rolled steel, it offers a sturdy feel that many bakers trust. If you need a larger pan for bigger pizzas, the standard diameter of this model will be too small for your needs.
When using this pan, remember that the cold-rolled steel is specifically engineered to promote uniform browning. If your dough isn’t browning evenly, ensure the pan is placed in the center of your oven rack to allow for maximum heat circulation.
Good if:
- You specifically look for PFAS-free bakeware.
- You want a versatile pan for flatbreads and reheating.
- You prefer a dishwasher-safe option.
Skip it if:
- You need a pan with a more expansive cooking surface.
- You’re looking for specialized handles or coatings.
- You require a material other than steel for your specific baking recipes.
7. TaiZhiBeFn 10 Inch Small Pizza Pan with Holes Nonstick Carbon
Best for: Apartment dwellers or anyone making single-serving personal pizzas.
This 10-inch pan is perfect for dorms, small kitchens, or casual snacks. Despite its small size, it’s built to handle temperatures up to 500°F, which is higher than many other options on this list. It’s made of carbon steel and features a perforated design to ensure your thin crust or frozen pizza gets that desired crunch.
The holes allow hot air to circulate underneath the dough. This releases excess moisture, which is the secret to achieving a golden, crunchy bottom on homemade or frozen crusts. If you notice your crust remains soggy, the perforations are likely blocked; ensure the dough doesn’t press directly into the holes to keep the airflow consistent.
It’s highly versatile, useful for roasting vegetables, bacon, or baking cookies in a toaster oven. While it’s dishwasher safe, the manufacturer suggests hand washing to help the nonstick coating last longer. The listing doesn’t mention the effect of metal utensils on the surface.
It isn’t intended for large family dinners, so keep that in mind if you have more than one or two people to feed.
Good if: * You have limited kitchen space or a small oven. * You want a pan that handles high heat up to 500°F. * You mostly bake personal pizzas or quick snacks.
Skip it if: * You need to feed more than two people at once. * You’re looking for a large-format pan.
Where These Overlap
Most of these pans share the same core goal: using perforations to eliminate soggy crusts. Whether you choose the Farberware, the Wilton, or the Emporio Kitchen model, you’re getting a carbon steel base that prioritizes even heat distribution.
The choice between them often comes down to size and convenience features rather than fundamental performance. For instance, the Wilton and casaWare models are very similar in footprint, yet they differ in their nonstick technology.
If you’re choosing between models of the same size, look at whether you prefer a dishwasher-safe finish or a specific handle design. If you need to handle the pan frequently, look for silicone grips like those on the ZOEHROWS model to prevent burns.
If you’re baking in a small space, a 10-inch pan is more practical for dorms or personal meals. If you’re cooking for a family, the 16-inch options provide the necessary surface area to avoid crowding. The differences are subtle, but they dictate how the pan fits into your specific kitchen routine.
Still Not Sure?
How often will I really use it?
If you bake pizza weekly for a family, a larger, durable option like the Emporio Kitchen 16 Inch Pan is a smart investment. If you only bake frozen snacks occasionally, a smaller, versatile pan like the TaiZhiBeFn Small Pizza Pan will serve you well without taking up too much storage space in your cabinet.
What do I already own that this has to work with?
Check your oven dimensions first. If you have a dedicated smart oven, the Breville Pizza Crisper is designed to fit those specific racks perfectly. If you have a standard wall oven, ensure your chosen pan fits the internal rack width, especially if you plan to use a larger model like the 16-inch trays.
What am I most likely to regret choosing?
The most common regret is buying a pan that’s too large to fit comfortably in your oven or too small to feed your family. Always measure your oven rack before buying. If you prioritize health standards, look for specific labels like the PFAS-free Wilton Non-Stick Pizza Pan to ensure your bakeware meets your personal requirements.
Most home bakers find that the right pan depends on their specific oven size and their typical serving size. If you want a standard, reliable pan for family meals, the Farberware Nonstick Crisper Pan is a frequent choice. For those with smaller ovens or personal cooking habits, the TaiZhiBeFn Small Pizza Pan is the way to go. Measure your oven, pick your size, and enjoy your crispier crusts.
FAQs Of Best Nonstick Pizza Pan With Holes for a Crispy Crust
Is it necessary to use a pizza stone instead of a perforated pan?
A perforated pan is generally easier to use and maintain than a pizza stone. While a stone is designed to absorb moisture, a perforated pan uses physical holes to release steam, which helps achieve a crispy crust without the long preheating time a stone requires. Pans are also less fragile and easier to clean than porous stones.
Can I put these pans in the dishwasher?
Many of the pans listed, such as the ZOEHROWS Pizza Pan and the Wilton Non-Stick Pizza Pan, are dishwasher safe. However, most manufacturers recommend gentle hand washing with a soft cloth to extend the life of the nonstick coating. Always check the specific care instructions for your model to avoid damaging the surface.
Why do some pans have silicone handles?
Silicone handles, like those on the ZOEHROWS Pizza Pan, are designed to make it safer and easier to grip the tray when it’s hot. They help prevent accidental burns when you’re sliding the pan into or out of the oven. These are particularly useful if you have a smaller oven where maneuvering a hot pan can be tricky.
Does the thickness of the metal matter for pizza pans?
Yes, metal thickness like the 0.6mm steel in the casaWare Perforated Pizza Pan or the Emporio Kitchen 16 Inch Pan helps prevent warping. A thicker, sturdier pan distributes heat more evenly and maintains its shape under high temperatures. This ensures your pizza bakes consistently across the entire surface without hot spots or uneven crust browning.
Conclusion
Once you’ve picked your favorite, you’ll be ready to start experimenting with different dough recipes and toppings. Don’t worry if your first attempt isn’t perfect; it’s all part of the fun. Grab your ingredients, preheat your oven, and you’ll be enjoying that crunchy, golden homemade slice in no time at all.
Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, I may earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you. Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon.com, Inc, or its affiliates.
